If you lost your memories and the knowledge of everything that was, would you still remain yourself? Ryan North explores the answer to that question in Fantastic Four #17.
Fantastic Four #17 is a tie-in to DNX, directly proceeding issue #2’s reveal that Magneto’s injured state requires an unnatural cure. It was revealed that every mutant’s physiology and biological makeup is extremely distinct. Unlike humans who share a vast majority of traits, the only thing mutants really have in common—besides basic makeup—is an active X-Gene. Magneto’s DNA specifically is extremely convoluted due to the complex nature of his powers.
It forces the F4 to think outside the box. The solution they arrive on is shrinking and entering Magneto’s body to fix it from the inside. Along the way, something happens that makes the 4 attack one other, and the only solution Sue has is to erase their memories. We pick up with them trying to figure out the situation, and who they are.
I enjoyed the mystery aspect of the chapter. It echoes the the previous issue—#16, one of the best F4 issues ever put to pen—in which we also started with a mystery. We were only told that the Fantastic Four have caused a civil war on another world, issuing a dramatic introduction that hooks the reader immediately. There was then a sequential mystery unfolding where we found out how the F4 caused it.
The same flow happens here, where we follow the F4 putting together the events piece by piece. The difference is that issue 16 shows a reverse chronology to arrive at the point of mystery. Additionally, the mystery was only one to the reader. Here, the reader and F4 are both in the unknown and work together to figure out what happened, and the investigation is ripe with hypotheses and clues.
It’s cool. I like that it’s utilizing a dramatic introduction that worked well last month, while making it different. It gains stakes initially because the 4 attack each other, posing a solid hook.
Another enjoyable thing is how the 4 don’t lose their essential characteristics despite the loss of memory. Reed is still intelligent, Johnny is still funny, Ben is still an empath, and Sue is still a caring analyst. All the lovable parts of our favorite fictional family are ingrained within them. And despite their core relationships—including memories of each and inside jokes—are missing, the issue still respectably builds a humorous and entertaining story without them.
I’ve rambled on enough about the loss of memory. Focusing on the regaining of them, I’m hoping for a flashback in how the situation arrived, due to the serious nature of the moral conflict behind it in DNX. Using an outcome-based framework, Reed initially refused to heal the former villain Magneto out of fear of what he might do sometime in the future. This hits hard, especially with the villain being Beast. If mutant oppression could change someone once as gentle as him, what would make a notorious villain like Magneto immune to another turn?
Sue told Reed that despite his morality and his logic conflicting with him, she can tell her husband honestly does want to heal Magneto. Accompanied by the presence of Magneto’s student Ben Liu, whom Magneto has helped tremendously and without hate-based philosophy, Reed can tell he’s changed for the better.
I hope that we can see that conversation and see how fully fleshed out, because it’s a rich discussion on what defines a person; their past, present, or both?
My one real moment of confusion is that in DNX, Johnny and Ben were in Philadelphia fighting alongside the X-Men. So how did they get home to the Baxter Building that quick? Could end up creating a weird continuity flow if not explained.
Otherwise, the issue was great, and I’m loving how smoothly the F4 were integrated into the X-Men centric storyline of DNX.
Rating: 4.1/5
Fantastic Four #18 by Ryan North released on October 28, 2026.

DISCUSSIONS (0)
Be the first to share your thoughts.